Investor Confidence Hits All-Time Low – Is It Time to Buy? — Evening Brief – 03.31.25
The American Association of Individual Investors (AAII) conducts a weekly survey of its members, polling them on whether they feel bullish, bearish, or neutral about the stock market’s direction over the next six months. As of the latest data available, the AAII Sentiment Survey reflects a predominantly negative outlook, though it showed a modest improvement in the most recent week.
Bearish sentiment remains unusually elevated. It has surpassed its historical average of 31% for the 16th time in the past 18 weeks, underscoring a persistent pessimism among individual investors. Notably, this marks a historic milestone: it’s the first time since the survey began in 1987 that bearish sentiment has exceeded 57% for four consecutive weeks. This streak surpasses even the most intense periods of gloom during the 2008 Financial Crisis, highlighting the depth of current investor unease.
Despite a slight uptick in the latest week, suggesting a minor easing of pessimism, the sustained high bearish readings contrast sharply with the analyst community’s optimism, where 55.7% of S&P 500 ratings are Buy, per FactSet. This divergence reflects a broader disconnect between individual investor sentiment and professional forecasts, possibly driven by looming uncertainties like the April 2 tariff deadline, sticky inflation and mixed economic signals. Historically, such extreme bearishness has often preceded market rebounds, though the unique economic context of 2025 keeps the outlook uncertain.
The AAII Sentiment Survey is widely recognized as a contrarian indicator in financial markets–a signal to buy (when sentiment is ultra-bearish) or to sell (when sentiment is super-bullish). When bullish sentiment climbs above 45%, the market is typically considered overbought, hinting at a possible sell-off as optimism peaks. Conversely, when bearish sentiment surpasses 45%, the market is deemed oversold, often a cue for contrarian investors to buy as pessimism hits extremes.
The unprecedented run—bearish sentiment exceeding 57% for four consecutive weeks—paints a starkly negative picture. This level of pessimism mirrors the intensity seen in the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX), a key gauge of market anxiety, which spiked to 29.56 on March 11, and remains elevated at 21.64. The AAII’s signal suggests a potential buying opportunity for contrarians.
The mood among Federal Reserve policymakers mirrors the pervasive uncertainty gripping markets, with most voting members opting for a cautious, wait-and-see approach to the April 2 tariff deadline and evolving trade policies. Fed Chair Jerome Powell has described this as an “unusually elevated” level of uncertainty, a sentiment echoed in the Fed’s reluctance to commit to targeted rate cuts. This hesitancy stems from mixed signals—soft data weakening while hard data holds firm—leaving the central bank in a holding pattern.
Yet, amid this gloom signs of bargain hunting are emerging. Investors are eyeing beaten-down sectors, such as those hit hardest by tariff fears or rate uncertainty, drawn by valuations that may now reflect oversold conditions. This great unwind of leverage and related margin calls may be over.